Take Your RFID and "Put it Where the Sun Don't Shine"
I read an article today on Yahoo.com about a school in the UK that is piloting a surveillance device in youths' school uniforms --RFID Chips in School Uniforms Track Students.
The devices are embedded in the uniforms of children between the ages of 11-16.
I was rather alarmed by the article. My first thoughts were "why are they tracking school age children?" I know some parents out there will say "it's for their protection." For their protection from who or what? If the assumption is the device will protect them from sexual predators, I still ask how. It is a known fact that most crimes committed against children occur from people they know. So how is a tracking device going to save your child when they are being molested by the baby sitter, a priest or a family relative. Are you hoping to protect them from being kidnapped? Most news reports I hear about youngsters being kidnapped always ends in the children being murdered. And I'm sure the criminals are aware of the RFIDs in the uniforms; a quick tug, rip, and toss of the uniform and you have a half-dressed child being taken from the school playground.
I ask again, what is the purpose of tracking your child? Is it a matter of trust? So Johnny or Jenny say they are going to be at a friend's house but they end up somewhere else. Do you think they are going to keep their uniform on to go to this new location when they know it has a tracking device in it?
How do you explain to your child this evasion of their privacy, this lack of trust?
The advocates for such surveillance devices on children like cell phones, video cameras in bedrooms and RFIDs will always say is to protect them...and I ask again "protect them from who and what."
I say get to the root cause of why children need to be protected and start there. I say harsher punishments for perpetrators of crimes against children, more intensive treatment for released sex-offenders, stricter rules about where they can live and work and be more critical of the companies that sexualize youth...put RFIDs in their attaché cases and wallets. I say more public dialog in schools, churches and communities about real people, real crimes and real motives.
All in all, the notion of surveillance creating safety is a hyped-up myth; it's an illusion that some people cling to because looking at real life is too hard for them to handle; looking at real life means you need to think and take action; it means you have to make some sacrifices on the weekends; it means you have to talk to other people and get involved in collective work; it means you have to hang up the cell phone, turn off the PDA, pause your iPod, and see, hear, feel what is going on around you; it means you have to be present; it means you have to be human.
Look around here in Baltimore; blue lights on every street corner, the "man" is watching you; police surveillance to "protect" you, keep you safe, cut down on illegal activity...yet the crime rates and drug traffic here tops the charts.
I say take your RFID and "put it where the sun don't shine."

